Monday, March 9, 2020

Eliza's Reflection on Literary Analysis 2

Informal, Online, or Multimedia Sources
- I did use one song in my paper, the song "Rise Against" by Hero of War. This was just another source for me to draw upon when proving my thesis. But it actually proved very helpful because the ideas reflected in the song were similar to the idea I was trying to write about. I could have definitely explored more multimedia sources, and other informal opinions and writings of Owen's poetry, and war in general. I looked into a few pictures, and they definitely influenced the tone of my paper, but music is something that has always struck a chord with me. There is something about certain types of audio that bring a work of literature to life. Following this same idea, hearing the poem read aloud also had an impact on the way that I read the poem, and the way that I wrote about it as well.

Literary Theory
- Because the focus of my paper was the transitional affect that war had on Owen's writing style, displayed in the transition of the narrator in his poem, the biographical source study played a huge role in my paper. I had studied this poem before, but had purely drawn from the literary elements displayed in the poem. Adding a theory such as biographical added so much to this paper! I had never known how dominating World War I had been in Owen's life. It was through this biographical source that I learned and incorporated in my paper that Owen was eventually killed in battle. Source studies was another literary theory that I implemented. It is pretty easy to recognize the transition in Owen's writing style simply by looking at his poetry, but looking into his sources allowed me to realize that it was the people around him that influenced his decision to transition his writing, even if fighting in the war itself is what changed his mindset from romanticism to realism.

Writing Process
- This process was a little bit of a struggle for me in the beginning, honestly. I really struggled to come up with one clear thesis that could be supported in the way that the assignment allotted. However, after revamping my thesis, I was able to not only have an easier time writing, but was able to get more excited about it as well. I loved the research part of this! I loved especially looking into informal sources, such as the song lyrics that I mentioned above. The research also led to a few study tangents, which I'm sure some of you are all too familiar with. There are so many fascinating articles about human morality and war, and I learned a lot outside of what I used in my paper!

Alyssa's Reflection on Literary Analysis 2


  • Informal, online, or multimedia resources:
    • This part of developing my paper is one that I hadn’t expected to be as useful to developing my argument, but turned out to be quite influential in the way that I wrote the paper. Looking at different portrayals and stage interpretations of Dr. Faustus helped me to see perspectives different from the one that I had developed after reading the script and stage directions. I enjoyed looking at the artwork of specific scenes in the play as well as the different approaches that different theater companies took in their performances. The main source that I used here was the Globe Theater’s production of Dr. Faustus, which I found to be a far more comical and symbolic interpretation than I had initially read in the text. The actors’ performances and interpretations of their characters had a great impact on how I wrote about the psychology of the titular Dr. Faustus.
  • Literary theory:
    • I chose to use the psychoanalytical approach to Dr. Faustus because it was different from the other approaches that I was more comfortable using, and I thought it would be a good exercise. As it turned out, this literary theory was just as helpful in highlighting the import of the soliloquies and the symbolic characters that I had chosen for formal analysis. Looking at these aspects of the play through a psychoanalytical lens helped me to make the connections between the form and my interpretation of it more clearly visible. Because the formal elements I was examining were indicative of the mindset of the character, using the psychological theory just made sense to use. 
  • Writing process:
    • My writing process has changed a bit since the beginning of the semester. Before, I would write when I could, and often spend too long self-editing the paper long before I ever finished it. Having a specific time to write, as we did for this assignment, was helpful for me to focus my thoughts and get the words onto the page that I needed to write down. Being accountable to someone else for the work that I did was also helpful, as it kept me focused on what I needed to do and made me less liable to getting distracted. I still needed to take a little extra time to write after spending perhaps too long on looking for good sources to support my argument, and I feel that this is where I can most improve in my writing process.




Ariel's Reflection on Literary Analysis 2

• Informal, online, or multimedia sources
  When I was first trying to find out a thesis statement or claim to make during my prewriting, I really wanted to make a positive claim for Hamlet. The internet had many different memes and blog posts and other social medias that made him selfish but relatable, his jump to conclusions funny, and showed that most people who like the play Hamlet like Hamlet more than most of the other characters. I made an attempt to mention this informally in my introduction. Then, I used a blog post about tragic heroes to explain in simple terms how a tragic hero archetype works. This helped me feel more comfortable knowing the definition was clearer and not just my own internal definition, and I was able to cover key components of the tragic hero in more of a list format – something I didn’t originally think to do.

• Literary theory
  I felt like it was easier to incorporate the literary theory more than formal analysis, and I focused heavily on trying to define the genre of tragedy before diving into Archetypal theory so I could cover both. In this case, it was easy to blend the formal and theory together using genre primarily. However, I was unsure if I should have done more to explain the theory in my paper, or if my subtle references and defining of certain terms was enough. It’s easy to make a claim, but I felt like I should have added more evidence somehow. I just don’t know in what way I could have done that. It might have also been beneficial to dissect certain pieces of the play with more formal analysis, but besides getting into genre and archetypes and evidence insinuating tragic hero traits, I was unsure what else I could have done to really tie the two components together in a stronger case. Any other formal attempts felt like I was getting side tracked with words rather than the overarching of archetypes.

• Writing process
  Like I usually do, I started by plotting out what I wanted to say for each paragraph. Then, I usually work on a starting thesis statement, write the intro and conclusion, then the body paragraphs. With this essay, the introduction and concluding paragraph were the last things I wrote. It was much more difficult finding a solid thesis to work with this time so I wrote the body paragraphs first, then the intro’s first few sentences and the conclusion’s last few, then reviewed what I was saying before attempting the thesis. This was beneficial because I could see what I was doing and where I was leaning toward, then I could re-tune certain sentences to fit the same case, then finally work on a thesis. I think my biggest strength is being able to find or reach conclusions/claims from evidence provided by plot and characters, but my weakness is definitely trying to analyze form and theory together to find more evidence. I can jump to conclusions but using sources to back me up is still difficult.

Hannah's Reflection on Literary Analysis 2

Informal Source
When I was in high school we studied A Streetcar Named Desire. I remember during the time that my friend who identifies as gay mentioned the influence that the play had on him. As I was writing this paper I remembered this conversation and asked him to send me a video explaining his experience reading and interpreting the play. This is what motivated me to approach Streetcar using queer theory and to understand the message that it conveyed concerning homosexuals and their struggles. I loved being able to have this kind of personal motivation to write this paper and to be able to connect it to somewhere who had personally experienced the struggles described in the play. At first I wasn't sure how to incorporate something so personal and so informal in my paper and so I ended up using a quote from him in my conclusion. I think this was able to solidify my argument and conclude my paper on a very realistic note.

Literary Theory
There were many different theories that I felt could help me analyze this paper, but I decided to use queer theory and some historical theory to support my argument. Because my claim and my theory were so interconnected it did not feel difficult to include both in my paper. However, I did struggle to synthesize the two throughout my paper, and found that at first I was separating my theory and my other analysis in to different paragraphs. After some revision, however, I was able to incorporate both to support each on of my paragraphs and claims.

Writing Process
Revision played a large role in this paper for me, perhaps more that it usually does when I am writing a paper. When I was writing this paper, I rearranged my paragraphs multiple times, focusing on meeting a specific claim in each paragraph with enough evidence to support that claim. I also found myself going back to my thesis after writing, too change it to better fit exactly what I was arguing throughout my paper. I also loved reading my paper out loud. As I did, I noticed different parts of my paper that were repetitive or unclear and was able to edit them. Without this part of the writing process I would have missed a lot of mistakes that were corrected pretty easily. One thing that I feel I need to continue to improve in my writing process is analysis of quotes. I think it would really help to break down the purpose of the quotes that I choose to include in my paper and why they contribute to the whole of my claim.

Jaidyn's Reflection on Literary Analysis 2


  • Informal and online sources: I felt pretty good about my use of online sources! I quoted directly from a syllabus I had found as an illustration of the universality of my literature. In addition, I was able to incorporate some images. One was from a film based on the book, and the others tied in with my literary theory of new historicism (two photos of the devastated Hiroshima). I wish I would have found something from social media, that would have added more depth and interest to my paper.
  • Literary theory: The theory of new historicism was pretty easy to use with my paper, and I feel like it was easy to blend the text and the theory. I was a little worried that I made too many assumptions, twisting the text to be what I wanted it to be. But I think that on the whole, there were some good connections back to historical context. I definitely could have talked about more formal elements. 
  • Writing process: So, I definitely saw what I need to improve about my writing process. For this paper, my rough draft was just a whole bunch of writing, which I then organized into cohesive paragraphs. After some frustration, I discovered that by making a very simple outline of my main points AFTER doing the bulk of the writing, it was easier to rearrange everything in an order that made sense. 

Rowen's Reflection on Literary Analysis 2

Informal, Online, Or Multimedia Sources

The book, Sea of Rust, is fairly recent, so it was difficult to find a lot of actual conversation about it online. Much of the informal resources I relied on had to do with my school of literary criticism, LDS Criticism. I used lesson plans from the Churchofjesuschrist.org website and institute manuals to inform my discussions of Restored Church of Christ doctrine. I couldn't site it since I don't have it, but I did also use the introduction to Asmiov's I, Robot to inform some of my understanding of robot fiction. Not a lot of that actually made it into the paper though.

Literary Theory

The main focus of my paper was LDS Criticism, which was a really interesting way to read a book that was largely focused on something I can only term atheistic concepts of deity. It was interesting to see how the various aspects of LDS doctrine and philosophy could be applied to a (probably) completely disconnected work of fiction. I also focused pretty heavily on genre criticism. One of the main points of my paper was how this book both utilizes and strays from the traditional conventions of robot fiction, and how those choices connect to the LDS concepts I was focusing on

Writing Process

It's really easy for me to write about things I get excited about. I was so excited for the Ozymandias paper, and even though it still needs improvement, I felt like each part of the process was much more natural. I had a much harder time getting started and moving forward with this paper, and I think that also affected how well it came out. I wasn't as motivated, so I didn't put in the work I should have to really make it polished. So that's something I need to focus on going forward, making sure I force myself to put in the right amount of work regardless of my motivation, because there are some projects I just won't enjoy as much as others. I'm also really struggling with actual formalist criticism. I have a lot of fun talking about overall concepts expressed within novels, but smaller-scale things that happen on a more formal level are really hard to reach for me.

Maddi's Reflection on Literary Analysis 2

  • Informal, online, or multimedia sources
    • I struggled a bit with this part of the essay. I found a lot of good content that influenced the way I wanted to write the book-- it gave me different perspectives and caused me to consider ideas that I hadn't originally noticed in "The Yellow Wallpaper". I felt that the material I found was very helpful and spawned original ideas, yet I wasn't sure how to incorporate them into my essay. The first thing I found was an art piece from Pinterest, depicting the woman in the text drowning, or being strangled, by the wallpaper. I loved this, because it was different from other pieces I had seen where she was trapped in/crawling out of the wallpaper. It showed that rather the wallpaper being a prison, it was more of a vice, and I inserted it into my essay to portray the hysteria I was referencing. Another I found was from a contemporary blog written by a teenage student, who found evidence within the text to represent an asylum-- and idea that I really loved! I wasn't sure how to use this in my text. Looking back, I wished I had used it early on to show how a modern take on the short story would look, however, I used it in my paper to outline these details, and then backed it up myself.
  • Literary theory.
    • I wanted to use a Historical/New Historical approach to the text, especially after looking at my informal source that brought up asylums. I wanted to use this a lot more in my text, but I found a hard time exploring it thoroughly while keeping to the word limit. However, I do think it ended up being effective, especially in showing the importance of recognizing hysteria within the text, and how it was used to create separation between peoples. It fit well with my formal analysis, as it usually does when looking at narrative or structure. In the future, I want to try to use a more complex approach to theory when blending it with my formal analysis.
  • Writing Process 
    • I spent a lot of time changing and developing my writing process. I started with a little bit of research to create an outline of the paper. I felt very excited and comfortable with it as I finished, however, upon further research, I decided to change my approach to the paper. Talking it out with my peers, and those in the class, really helped me to regain a comfortable approach to the paper. I decided to compare "The Yellow Wallpaper" to "The Picture of Dorian Gray" and use it as a way to bring the elements in "The Yellow Wallpaper" that I found to be significant. This helped a lot, and helped me to revise my outline. However, after my first draft, my paper didn't seem to have all the pieces I wanted it to-- it felt lacking and too wordy! I decided to go through and find quotes and arguments I wanted in my paper, that I felt should drive the paper, and created a new outline from there. I then went through and cut what didn't fit the mold! This last method really helped me to organize my thoughts and make a stronger argument throughout my paper. I feel that I need to better solidify my argument before/during my writing process and really stick to it. I found that my original argument wasn't fully formed, and it took me a few tries to refigure it.