Friday, February 21, 2020

Critical Approaches to "The Yellow Wallpaper" by Charlotte Perkins Gilman

I chose to research "The Yellow Wallpaper", a text that focuses on the descent into delirium by a woman who's suffering from post-partum depression. Her husband is a physician and recommends that she refrain from any sort of intellectual exhaustion, and moves them together to a new house for three weeks to help her recover. Here, while not being able to do anything besides sit in a bedroom all day and sleep, the main character is driven crazy--- supposedly by the ugly yellow wallpaper. I chose to research this text because although it was originally written for mental illness awareness, it has been reduced to merely feminist themes and ideas. I feel like the text has meaning that goes beyond those ideas, and I want to explore it through this assignment.

[Disability Studies]
I thought I could focus on ableism in the text, where instead of focusing on her mental fatigue, focusing on her desire to write. How of all the activities she needs to refrain from, it appears that writing is one she is most worried of being caught doing. To her, intellectual rest is not what she needs, but instead writing makes her feel better. All the while, her husband and sister-in-law see it as what drove her to madness. Writing seems to be the cause of prejudice from her family.

[New Historicism]
I want to look into the diagnosis of women with illnesses at the time, as well as mental illness. Charlotte Gilman was diagnosed with mental illness and that was her stated reason for writing the text, however I would like to look more into the cultural stigma of the diagnosis, and how the patients were treated. I think in understanding the stigma behind these illnesses, as well as the way they were understood then, would help me to then analyze how it influenced the way Gilman presented the text, or the way others then would interpret the text-- especially in regards to her illness being a state of mind and something to think away, or more of a physical illness. This would go back to exploring the original purpose of the text stated by Gilman.

[Archetypal Criticism]
I would like to look into the different character archetypes embedded within the text, and how they begin to stray from the archetype and morph into new ones. The main character, who remains unnamed, starts out as the hero and protagonist, however slowly becomes what seems like an antagonist throughout the text. The wallpaper itself, as well as the journal she's writing in, also morph into crucial characters within the text. I want to look into the shadow character archetypes to see what meaning can be pulled from both the main character, the wallpaper, and the journal, all existing as the shadow character at some point in the text.

[Psychoanalytical Criticism]
This theory is wildly overused on this text, however I want to take what is hopefully a new approach. I want to focus on the aspect of "collective unconscious" for this piece. The main character seems to have an innate desire and need to write, which I feel like is connected to an ancestral memory of recording history. I want to connect it to evidences of cave art, and our earliest known hero epics, and how the writings in the journal resemble those themes of recorded stories, but also of a hero's journey, or a hero's downfall that could be compared to the character development of our main character.


4 comments:

  1. I really like your approach with all of these theories! Each of them seems to connect with the others. In particular, I think the New Historicism theory would be especially interesting to research and connect to how writing was also viewed in the context of physical and mental wellness.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I like the idea of focusing on ableism for disability studies, but I'm curious how ugly wallpaper could be the catalyst to drive her "insane." If she's mentally exhausted and fighting PTSD, there must be more that builds up her insanity other than just the wallpaper, more than just feministic themes, like a gradual descent.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I think that it would be interesting to write about the social stigma's surrounding mental illness at the time as well. I wonder that if back then you were just labeled as crazy if diagnosed or if people understood treated it as they did physical illness? Maybe because of the stigma this woman suffered more in her day than she would have in ours?

    ReplyDelete
  4. Wow I think your archetypal angle sounds really interesting! I think it would be cool to deep dive with that. Also I just feel like there is some good unpacking that could be done with the sister-in-law--especially under disability studies there is a lot you could focus on with her.

    ReplyDelete